Here is the list of signers and their comments through September 24, 2009, the day the petition was closed due to the successful outcome: the creation of the National Shark Sanctuary in Palau.
In addition to these signatures, we have received 164 signatures on paper from Japanese citizens, collected by Pangea Seed.
3756. Not publicly disclosed, Scarborough, WA, Australia
3755. Not publicly disclosed, Miami, Florida, United States
3754. Not publicly disclosed, Au/Waedenswil, Switzerland
3753. Christina Rolston, Queensville, Canada
3752. Richard Byard, Sydney, Australia
3751. Rebekah Booth, Mentone, Victoria, Australia
3750. Not publicly disclosed, Trenton, Ontario, Canada
3749. Not publicly disclosed, Saint Louis, Missouri, United States
Sharks are worth more to tourism alive than dead. Once they are gone, they are gone forever. If you protect them, and as a consequence, the entire ecosystem, you can make much, much more money on these sharks over and over again if they are alive and keeping the islands balanced.
Please, please reconsider shark fishing. They are disappearing at an alarming rate over the world.
Please help save them!
Thank you.
3748. Dan Ginsburg, Washington, District of Columbia, United States
3747. Nick Jeans, Paris, France
3746. Not publicly disclosed, Ramsey , United Kingdom
3745. Not publicly disclosed, Derry, New Hampshire, United States
3744. Rahnae Hawkins, Yokine, Western Australia, Australia
3743. John Carmichael, St Andrews, Fife, United Kingdom
3742. Amanda Cloutier, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
3741. Not publicly disclosed, London, United Kingdom
slow acting or corrupt governments are letting the world down. Their ranks will one day hold the guilt of their inaction.
3740. Mark Deusenberry, Coatesville, Pennsylvania, United States
3739. Not publicly disclosed, Chelles, France
STOP
Arrêtons le massacre avant qu'il ne soit trop tard!!!!!!!!!
3738. Not publicly disclosed, London , United Kingdom
3737. Robert Verduyn, Dundas, Ontario, Canada
3736. Greg Johnston, Manhasset, New York, United States
3735. Not publicly disclosed, Oakville, Ontario, Canada
3734. Viv Cecil, Herstmonceux, East Sussex, United Kingdom
3733. Ross Pooley, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Please dont re-start shark fishing. They need all the protection they can get, as they face extinction.
I would like to visit Palau one day for a diving holiday, but only if you have thriving shark populations.
3732. Annette Schmaltz, Berlin, Germany
3731. Julien Rubiano, Paris, France
3730. Daniel van Duinkerken, Utrecht, Netherlands
3729. Thi Le Dung Nguyen, Paris, France
Shark fins cartilage does not have special good health effect, (if there is any ) than any other animal or fish cartilage, SO PLEASE, STOP SLAUGHTER THEM IN THE NAME OF HEALTH !!!
3728. Jennifer Kathol, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
3727. Raymond Mann, New Jersey, New Jersey, United States
3726. Alexia Fanni, Geneva, Switzerland
3725. Not publicly disclosed, Montataire, France
3724. Petra Ruskovska, Secovce, Slovakia
3723. Ann Johnson, Eastbourne, United Kingdom
3722. Hysa Hysa, Rignac, Aveyron, France
3721. Sabrina Moucadeau, barbentane, France
3720. Not publicly disclosed, Sydney, Australia
3719. Claudia Peters, Maastricht, Limburg, Netherlands
Sharks are the most essential creatures to keep the oceans healthy !!!
3718. Emily King, Cambridge, United Kingdom
3717. Not publicly disclosed Erlenbach, Switzerland
3716. Not publicly disclosed, Lyon, France
3715. Phil Harbour, Brighton, East Sussex, United Kingdom
3714. Dena Jones, Singapore, Singapore
3713. Holger Burmester, Hamburg, Germany
3712. Marian Hussenbux, Birkenhead, United Kingdom
3711. Luke Davies, Reading, Berks, United Kingdom
3710. Not publicly disclosed, Rawai Beach, Phuket, Thailand
3709. Michael Botti, Yangmei, Taiwan
As a frequent diver in the waters of Palau, I've already seen the decline in the resident gray reef shark population, and have seen with my own eyes the "bycatch" (shark fin) drying in the sun on top of these Taiwan owned fishing vessels. To allow them further permission to exploit/deplete the top end of the food chain is nothing short of criminal.
Eco tourists the world over flock to Palau's pristine natural environment, and I myself have spent thousands of dollars over the years strictly on the premise that the Palauan government remains environmentally proactive towards shark conservation. The short term gain can only very temporarily cover the rape of the local pelagic population that will occur should this come into law. One can only imagine the fallout from negative publicity, and divers will turn away in droves once they discover the "8th wonder of the world" is actually more interested in giving a flip-flop wearing taxi driver in Shenzhen a "special soup experience" than it is preserving one of the last places on earth where the ocean's top end predators still exist in numbers.
If this passes, you'll have at least one less diving tourist. The idea of seeing Palau's magnificent dropoffs without the majesty of the ever-present gray reef sharks would be to horrifying to contemplate.
No Palaun I've ever met would possibly be in support of Bill 8-44.
It's ecological suicide...Do not do this!
Michael Botti
3708. Not publicly disclosed, Ruscombe, United Kingdom
3707. James Gardner, Otaki, New Zealand
3706. Jenny Bouttier, Montpellier, France
3705. Christophe Moille, Montreuil, Ile-de-France, France
3704. Amanda Ingram, Canberra, Australia
3703. Rebecca Hutchison, Okotoks, Alberta, Canada
3702. Aneliese Krulicki, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Please do not support Bill 8-44.
3701. Julie van Niekerk, Grasland,Ten Acres, Gauteng, South Africa
The future of out planet and ocean lies in preserving, not destroying.
3700. Maria Borremans, Brussels, Brussels Gewest, Belgium
do not damage the ecosystem by destroying the shark population - do not act in an irresponsible way
3699. Jason Lister, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
3698. Michael Hall, Huntington Beacg, California, United States
These are the coolest mammals on the planet....
3697. Toby Rabiner, New York, New York, United States
are you in ny now?
3696. Kent Backman, Honolulu, Hawaii, United States
Hi -
I first started diving Palau in 1993, and the main attraction for me back then was the sharks. I would love to continue to come back to Palau to dive, but will absolutely plan to never come again if the Palau government passes the legislation to allow shark fishing.
3695. Not publicly disclosed, Paea, French Polynesia
3694. Karin Leonard, Westfield, Massachusetts, United States
Divers, eco tours bring much more $$$ as opposed to fishing. In the long term there will always be tourism income however once the sharks are fished out that income is gone.
3693. Not publicly disclosed, Jungholtz, Alsace, France
There have been several major disasters on our planet:
- Super volcanic eruption,
- Great asteroid impact,
Today we go to another catastrophe:
- Super human shit!
Only positive thing in all these events:
The earth has given and repeated every time beautiful things (without Humains)
But it is a shame for our future generations
3692. Stephane Kolb, Thann, France
3691. Brandon Aberg, San Diego, California, United States
3690. Eileen Hennessy, Melrose, Massachusetts, United States
One hundred million sharks are killed every year. This madness must stop! As a tourist, I would not wish to visit a place that contributes to the decimation and possible extinction of these magnificent animals.
3689. Not publicly disclosed, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
3688. Carter Bland, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
3687. Kirk Bland, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
3686. Janeen Bland, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
3685. Andrew Maciver, Sydney, NSW, Australia
3684. Tara Paget, Sydney, Australia
3683. Not publicly disclosed, Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
Save the Shark
3682. Chris Vestuto, Goleta, California, United States
I go on dive trips every year in other countries, and I try to do things that help rather than hurt the local ecology and economy. I would NEVER travel to a place that allows finning!
3681. Not publicly disclosed, Memphis, Tennessee, United States
3680. Sloane Becker, Dallas, Texas, United States
3679. Schaeffer Becker, Plano, Texas, United States
3678. Serge Gascon, Gatineau, Quebec, Canada
This is definitely not the best way of promoting tourism by destroying the natural equilibrium that you are privileged to have. Never underestimate the value of tourism!
3677. Not publicly disclosed, Milford, United States
I dove in Palau earlier this year and had the privledge to swim with numerous sharks. These beautiful creatures need to be protected to protect the whole marine ecosystem. Shark fishing is a short term solution. Maintaining our planet should far outweigh short term economic gains. Palau can sustain ecotourism longer than shark fishing. Please, wholeheartedly reject SB 8-44.
3676. Not publicly disclosed, Hanhofen, Germany
3675. Alexandra Prater, Edwardsville, Illinois, United States
i love sharks
3674. Andrea McGiboney, Newnan, Georgia, United States
3673. Not publicly disclosed, stouffville, Canada
3672. Yoko Tsurumi, Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
I heard that sharks are having their fins cut and abandoned to the sea though they are still living....Since then, I stopped to eat shark
3671. Not publicly disclosed, Neckarhausen, Germany
3670. Not publicly disclosed, Tokyo, Japan
3669. Not publicly disclosed, Toyama, Japan
3668. Not publicly disclosed, Gardelegen, Germany
3667. Tracie Nail, Altoona, Pennsylvania, United States
3666. Brice Rembert, Irvington, New Jersey, United States
3665. Katrina Goodson, Virginia Beach , Virginia, United States
Sharks are an essential resource for the ocean environment, they are being killed faster than they can sustain themselves. Please help reverse this.
3664. Randy Glaze, Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States
3663. Not publicly disclosed, Lake Forest, California, United States
3662. Craig Weir, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
3661. Bryan Duffy, Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
3660. Not publicly disclosed, Milford, Michigan, United States
Please . . . one of the most beautiful environments on earth . . . don
3659. Patricia Baker, Bellevue, Washington, United States
3658. Richard Wise, Louisville, Kentucky, United States
3657. Victoria Singley, Houston, Texas, United States
Shark fishing for short-term gain just destroys the long-term gain for Palau. My son and I took a dive trip to Palau a few years ago, and the chance to see a lot of sharks was the MAIN reason that we chose Palau. If you destroy the shark population, you will lose most of your dive tourism dollars. PLEASE PROTECT YOUR WATERS AND MARINE LIFE!!